The fallacy of sunscreen. The importance of slime. A better release
By Skip Clement
NOTE: Bonefish and Tarpon Trust (BTT) has gathered an enormous amount of information about bonefish, as well as Tarpon, and of late, permit. We picked from the battery of the BTT scientific database and created an assemblage of some interesting facts.
We limited our coverage to the Abula spookus, and we don’t attempt to present it as a “story.” More as of interest – facts about the iconic spookus.
It is roundly believed that tobacco products, a fuel of any kind, and sunscreen are feeding deterrents to bonefish. Well, we can rule out one angler-perpetuated myth for sure; sunscreen. That, thanks to Kelly Hannan, Aaron Shultz, Zach Zuckerman, and Chris Haak. All scientists with bonefish on their minds
NOTE: All of the information presented sourced from Bonefish & Tarpon Trust’s magazine, blogs, newsletters, press releases, and BTT’s Symposium Abstracts and Presentations.
Are bonefish less likely to consume bait (or a fly) contaminated by sunscreen?
The Experiment: Assess whether bonefish show an aversion to sunscreen-contaminated bait (fly). Bonefish were collected from nearby flats and held at Bahamas’ Cape Eleuthera Institute (CEI) wet lab for a series of observations on their feeding behaviors. Experimental trials consisted of supplying bonefish with shrimp handled with oxybenzone-containing sunscreen (conventional sunscreen), zinc-based sunscreen, or clean wet hands.
Researchers observed how long it took a bonefish to bite and spit the bait and measured the total weight of treated shrimp consumed. Results indicated that bonefish feeding behavior was unaffected by the addition of conventional and zinc sunscreens to the bait, and fish were neither attracted by nor dissuaded to consume contaminated bait. They didn’t consume a different amount of shrimp when sunscreen was added and the time of their first bite did not change.
Considering that bonefish rely primarily on their eyesight to identify prey, these results may not be surprising. Anglers should be more concerned with their choice of the fly than what they last touched when it comes to hooking fish.
The Experiment: How do sunscreen products and UV-blocking gloves affect fish health following handling? To examine the effects of handling a fish with contaminated hands, researchers simulated an angling event in the lab; fish were exercised via tail grabbing (a standard technique) around a large tank for 4 minutes. Then handled and air-exposed for 1 minute to simulate hook removal.
Researchers coated their hands with either conventional oxybenzone-containing sunscreen, zinc-based sunscreen, donned UV-blocking gloves, or had clean wet hands before handling. Mucous removed by the researcher’s hands was weighed and recorded.
Mucous, otherwise known as a fish’s slime layer, is the first defense line for a fish. Slime removal is known to increase the likelihood of infection in fish, which in extreme cases can result in post-release mortality.
Results suggest that oxybenzone-containing sunscreen removed significantly more mucous than zinc-based sunscreen, gloves, or wet hands, and wet hands resulted in the least amount of mucous lost across all treatments.
Throughout the experiment, only two fish displayed bacterial infection evidence following handling, and both fish were exposed to the zinc sunscreen treatment. Based on these results, anglers should consider avoiding handling fish with sunscreen-coated hands, as well as with UV gloves.
To best protect oneself from the sun with bonefish welfare in mind, rely on UV-blocking gloves, but remove them before handling a fish.
Keep the bonefish in the water to avoid excess air exposure, and ensure your hands are wet to minimize mucous loss.
For some reason, one difficult to explain, bonefish are of particular interest to this magazine’s editors. We’ve both fished for them in distant places: Florida Keys; Isla de Culebra, Puerto Rico; Belize; Yucatan, Mexico; the Bahamas and Turks & Caicos. Serendipitously, all bonefish destinations that BTT has ongoing investigative studies.
NOTE: Featured Image is the Bahamas captured bonefish. Photo Bonefish & Tarpon Trust.
Join Bonefish & Tarpon Trust . . . you deserve it