Long Key Fishing Club, the beginning of saltwater fishing as a sport
By Skip Clement and Capt. Andrew Derr
Zane Grey, a dentist from Zanesville, Ohio, and grand-daddy of the western novel was a frequenter at the Long Key Fishing Club after he and his brother, RC (Roemer), discovered it by chance.
In 1910, the Grey’s were on their way to Mexico for a fishing trip but learned of an epidemic and made their way back to Cuba and Florida.
On a hunch that there had to be great fishing in the Florida Keys, they made their way to Long Key via Henry Flagler’s new rail line extension built to eventually service riders from NY to Key West and beyond to Cuba.
Zane Grey gave international fishing prowess to the Long Key Fishing Club and the Florida Keys.
King Mackerel [Palm Beach, FL] would no longer be the only sports fish of the day nor would the rod, line, reel or rigging ever be the same.
At the Long Key Fishing Club (LKFC), Zane Grey would introduce light tackle fishing, make proper the sport of bonefishing, sail fishing, and tarpon fishing. All of which thought to be nuisance catches. Grey made them all worthy sport fishing challenges. Grey’s accomplishments as a sports fisherman set the bar so high that celebrities of the day would become “Gentlemen Sports Fisherman.” All would measure themselves against Grey’s feats, including Hemingway.
Grey’s accomplishments as a sports fisherman set the bar so high that celebrities of the day would become “Gentlemen Sports Fisherman,” a new class for the upper-income lads and lassies.
Zane Grey was the first to promote the release of catches not scheduled for the table, a radical thought in the early 1900s and even a few decades ago. Today, there are still several remaining Neanderthals bent on killing fish and game just for the boast of it, unfortunately.
Zane Grey was also a naturalist, easily swayed from a day with rod and reel “. . . So much beauty and wildlife, so wild that it was tame, seemed a rare and marvelous fact of nature. The great spirit of creation was brooding here.”
Zane Grey and his brother were also the first to go after sailfish, tarpon, and bonefish as sports fish. “I believe I have proved to myself – that the sailfish is the ‘gamest,’ the most beautiful, and the hardest fish to catch on light tackle.”
Zane Grey helped define a completely new sport, Light Tackle Fishing
Zane Grey made the LKFC famous and Presidents Hoover and Teddy Roosevelt, as well as other notables of the day, would be visitors between 1910 and its last season in 1934. The LKFC would never recover from the 1935 Labor Day Hurricane.
The LKFC was revitalised in the late 60’s with charter members of note:
Ted Williams, Arthur Godfrey, Jackie Gleason, Mike Douglas and Jimmy Carter (before he was President of the United States). The club never really got going because the state eminent domained the property of Long Key and turned it into a park that is in use today and still a good place to fish.
Impact: Long Key Fishing Club (1910 to 1934) created a new view of sport fishing – it was embraced by the ordinary citizen
• Zane Grey’s 10-pound, 5-ounce bonefish was the LKFC and world record for many years.
• Zane Grey’s 130 -pound tarpon was then a world record.
• Zane Grey introduced sailfish fishing.
• Zane Grey probably introduced the world to the ‘teaser’ and, essentially, bait-and-switch when he began his love of sail fishing and then bill fishing.
• Zane Grey proposed to all he met and fished with that it would be a good practice to throw back the fish you did not intend to eat.
• Zane Grey rarely fished without a guide or offshore captain.
• Zane Grey and his brother,
Roemer were keen naturalists and accomplished photographers.
• Zane Grey established bonefish as a target species at the LKFC, and it attracted a new cult of believers called the “Bonefish Brigade.”
The ‘brigade’ fished for the silver ghost a little differently than we do today. Try this today and see if you get a dozen or so bones every day! The brigade fished for bones from a chair set at the shoreline.
It had become fashionable to catch your bait, so sweating a bit was not out-of-the-question. Bait, hook, and sinker was cast out as far as possible in more or less a foot of water, and according to accounts, one sat with his finger on the line waiting to feel the tug, which rarely took a minute or two to hook an 5-pound bonefish.
Source: Fly Fishing The Florida Keys, [Skip Clement and Capt. Andrew Derr] Amato 2005.